Skip to main content


How Can I Tell if it's Silver or Silver Plated?

In the world of antiques, the line between silver and silver-plated can be deceptively thin. As dealers, we’ve all seen it—the moment someone brings in a cherished piece, convinced it’s solid silver, only for a closer examination to reveal otherwise. It’s an easy mistake to make; after all, silver-plated items were crafted to mimic their solid counterparts, often with impressive skill. But understanding the difference is essential, not just for assessing value but for appreciating the craftsmanship and context of each piece. Allow me to share the most reliable methods of identification, each with its own advantages and pitfalls, to help you discern the genuine article from its plated counterpart. You can, of course, reach out to DC Silver (www.dcsilver.com) for guidance about specific items.

1. Hallmark Examination

Method: Look for hallmarks or stamps. Sterling silver often bears marks like "925" or "Sterling," while plated items might carry terms such as "EPNS" (Electroplated Nickel Silver) or "Silverplate."

  • Pros: Non-invasive; highly reliable if the marks are legible and authentic.
  • Cons: Fakes and worn marks can mislead; some country marks can be obscure. Not all solid silver is marked at all.

2. Nitric Acid Testing

Method: Apply a silver-testing acid in a discreet area. Solid silver reacts distinctly compared to plated metals.

  • Pros: Highly accurate when done properly.
  • Cons: Requires skill and good judgment. Acid can scar silver if used improperly

3. Ultrasound or XRF Analysis

Method: High-tech approaches like X-ray fluorescence (XRF) precisely identify the metal’s composition.

  • Pros: Accurate and non-invasive.
  • Cons: Expensive and not easily accessible for casual collectors. XRF only penetrates so many microns into silver, so heavily plated items can give false readings.

4. Scratch Test

Method: Lightly scratch the surface in an inconspicuous area to see if a base metal is revealed.

  • Pros: Straightforward and effective.
  • Cons: Causes damage; unsuitable for valuable or antique pieces.

5. Magnet Test

Method: Use a magnet. Solid silver is non-magnetic, while plated items may use magnetic base metals like steel or nickel.

  • Pros: Quick, cheap, and non-invasive. Good for scanning a pile of jewelry.
  • Cons: Some plated items use non-magnetic metals, leading to false positives. 

6. Weight Comparison

Method: You can conduct a specific gravity test on silver.

  • Pros: Non-invasive and useful for experienced dealers.
  • Cons: Technically can be complicated for some

7. Conductivity Test

Method: Test the thermal or electrical conductivity of the piece. Silver is an excellent conductor compared to most base metals.

  • Pros: Scientific and non-damaging.
  • Cons: Requires specialized equipment and expertise.

Words of Wisdom

Each method has its place, depending on the piece and the stakes. For the novice, hallmarks and a good loupe are your best starting tools. But remember, even the best techniques can falter in the face of clever forgeries. Approach every new piece with both curiosity and caution—solid silver has a story worth preserving, and part of that story lies in knowing it for what it truly is.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Power of Silver Hallmarks

Hallmarks can be extremely powerful and important in silver.  They tell the story of many pieces of silver that is absent on most other kinds of antiques.  For the furniture enthusiast, there are sometimes paper labels or pencil mark signatures, but these are rare.  For silver, the marks are often there, and when they are, you need to pay heed.  The absence of a hallmark can also be significant but we'll get into that later.  In this little article, I want to describe the non-US hallmarks that have been the most important to me in my business dealings.  The photos are pieces I have bought and/or sold some of which are still available at Crescent City Connection in my silver section .  I make a description of some of these marks and use many thematically similar pieces to give those descriptions.  I don't claim these are the best of the best pieces, just items I've been able to trade. For me, at my current stage of collecting, nothing could be w...
3 comments
Read more

Fakes in the Silver and Gold Trade - A Few Examples

I wanted to write today about something that happens from time to time to dealers-- even with pretty sharp eyes.  Fakes.  The fact is that almost all dealers have bought fakes.  You won't see that many articles, because it's embarrassing and dealers think telling people about screw ups might hurt the reputation.  The fact is, publishing these images may help others who are about to get burned or who will remember these examples in the future.  Have a good image of a fake?  Send it along and I will add it to this post. Fake 1736 Spanish 8 Escudo Sometimes you get burned by a counterfeit-- or other times just valueless items that lend an appearance of being a good score.  Sometimes these fakes are intentionally fake and sometimes they are not.  But either way, if you have integrity you should never pass them along even as "replicas" and it would be better if you spotted them before you plunked down your cash and didn't buy them at all.  N...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Beckley-Lincoln Book

Debates, Resolutions & Other Proceedings, of The Convention of the Commonwealth of MA to Which the Federal Constitution is Prefixed The 1789 title page inscribed by the owner, John James Beckley Once in a while. Once in a while you see a book that is so much more than a book. More than a leather binding and all the wear of the dirty fingertips over tallow candles. Sometimes you find a book that talks and breathes, that lives its history and the history of our nation with it. I want to tell you about John Beckley's book. It almost certainly wasn't his only book. He was a learned man. The largest collection of books in the country at that time was probably Thomas Jefferson-- some 6,500 volumes. More typically, people owned a few volumes and the very wealthy maybe owned a few dozen. As Brian Hoey once said, "Some studies suggest that as many 60 percent of colonial households owned at least one book". And more to the point, "..while many people owned ...
Post a Comment
Read more